Cold Email vs LinkedIn Outreach: Whats Winning in 2025?

Lets be real cold outreach works, but its getting harder to do right

Moiz Khurram

I have been in the cold email trenches for years, When its dialed in, its a machine

But the landmines are everywhere:

  • Constantly warming domains

  • Monitoring inbox reputation

  • Bounce rate drama

  • Diminishing open rates

  • And yeah getting buried in spam filters

Lately though, I have been running a pretty wild experiment
One that completely sidesteps deliverability issues and gets 2 to 3x more replies

Lets break down what I have found

Cold Email: Still a Beast If You Have the Right Stack

Cold email is still elite, But only if you:

  • Have an amazing offer

  • Nail personalization

  • Avoid the overused data sources (looking at you, Apollo)

To make cold email work today, you need fresh leads, Thats where tools like Scrapeamax come in, It lets you scrape unlimited company lead lists from places like GMB, BuiltWith, Clutch and more so you are not blasting the same 10K contacts everyone else is

Pair that with a strong cold email system like what we teach in the Leadamax Cold To Closed Toolkit and you are golden

But lets talk about the next level strategy thats outperforming even that

Profile Based Outreach via LinkedIn (The Deliverability Killer Hack)

Instead of using burner domains or faceless emails, what if you reached out as you?

I tested a LinkedIn first outreach system powered by Prosp and the results have been crazy:

  • You show up with your real face, brand and profile

  • No inbox warmups, no spam filters, no domain headaches

  • You’re in the DMs of your dream clients, without friction

Its not about automating spammy messages, Prosp lets you scale hyper personalized profile based outreach with logic, personalization and real intent and people actually reply

Trust goes up, Response rates go up And you skip all the messy deliverability nonsense

So… Which One Should You Use?

Heres a quick breakdown:

Category

Cold Email (Scrapeamax + Toolkit)

LinkedIn Outreach (Prosp)

Reach

Mass outreach, faster TAM coverage

Slower but hyper-targeted

Deliverability

Needs setup, warming, domain health management

No deliverability issues at all

Trust Factor

Depends on copy + case studies

Higher profile based trust

Best Use Case

Scalable outbound if offer is dialed in

Warm style prospecting for high value accounts

Tech Stack

Scrapeamax, Smartlead, Whop Toolkit

Prosp

The Hybrid Play means Best of Both Worlds

Heres what I am doing now:

  1. Scrape unlimited high quality leads using Scrapeamax

  2. Filter and segment using custom ICP logic

  3. Run cold email sequences for scale

  4. Layer on LinkedIn outreach with Prosp to engage top tier leads

  5. Close using scripts and workflows from Cold to Closed

The combo is unbeatable: scale and personalization, Volume and trust

BOOK A FREE OUTBOUND AUDIT

Latest articles